Normalises ‘violent masculinity’: DCPCR asks NCERT to change Class 9 textbook
[ad_1]
The Delhi Fee For Safety of Youngster Rights has requested NCERT to change or change a chapter in Class IX English textbook, claiming that it normalises "violent masculinity, depicts girls in "stereotypical methods and teaches youngsters to just accept violence at dwelling".
The panel's chief Anurag Kundu stated the chapter titled 'The Little Woman' narrates the story of a woman Kezia, who's terrified of her father and is continually threatened by him to some extent that it begins impacting her speech.
Later in a tweet, Kundu wrote, "I've written to @ncert Director advising removing of the chapter 3 titled "The Little Woman" of sophistication IX English textbook because it normalises violent masculinity, perpetuates patriarchy and promotes poisonous behaviour within the household."
No fast response was out there from the NCERT.
Based on the story, Kezia's grandmother asks her to arrange a present for her father as his birthday is across the nook. She prepares a pin cushion, however stuffs it with papers which include a speech her father is meant to ship at an occasion.
On discovering this out, the daddy beats her up, however the grandmother asks her to overlook the incident.
Within the evening, whereas sleeping beside her father, Kezia "realises" that the daddy works too exhausting to be enjoying together with her, and that explains him getting offended steadily. She forgets concerning the incident and forgives him, the DCPCR stated.
The panel stated it consulted gender specialists over the chapter and concluded that "it's deeply problematic".
It stated Kezia's grandmother and mom are proven in stereotypical methods.
"Each girls are docile, unable to face as much as the daddy when he beats or screams at Kezia. The mom is proven as an enabler of the abuse and patriarchy in the home.... The grandmother is sort and compassionate, lovingly soothes her granddaughter, however by no means defends her... Her grandmother, being an elder, is proven as powerless in entrance of her son," the letter to NCERT director learn.
Noting that this "portrayal of ladies is at odds with the type of gender equal society all of us aspire to construct", the panel careworn that youngsters should be uncovered to extra progressive portrayal, making them query and critically look at her personal environment.
"It teaches youngsters to just accept violence at dwelling as a result of the daddy works too exhausting... The fabric doesn't empower women in any manner, and actually, gives dangerous examples that women and younger girls can forgive perpetrators of violence whereas boys can be taught that they are going to be forgiven even when they're violent... All characters appear to be caught in a psychologically unsafe surroundings," the letter stated.
Kundu careworn that textbooks play an vital function in shaping younger minds as they develop as much as problem the notions of misogyny and violence.
"Chapters resembling this can be a self-defeating train to that finish. Subsequently, I request your sort intervention to both modify the chapter suitably or change the chapter from the textbook for the 2023-24 tutorial yr onwards," he added.
This story has been revealed from a wire company feed with out modifications to the textual content. Solely the headline has been modified.[ad_2]
0 comments